Below the Waterline · Issue 1

On loyalty and founder dependency.

Why the people who never disagree with you are often the reason nothing runs without you – and the sharper question to ask instead of who’s loyal.

By Simon Wakeman, Principal Consultant & Fractional COO
· 3 minute read

As a founder you might call someone loyal because they put in the extra weekend shift when it’s needed and back your call in the room even when they think it’s wrong. It feels like exactly what you need. But in reality those things might be the reasons why nothing runs without you.

Why the people who never disagree with you are the reason nothing runs without you

The version of loyalty most founders reward is agreement. It’s someone staying attached to you specifically rather than to the outcome. That’s a comfortable thing to have around when you’re firefighting daily, because it means one less argument in a day that’s already full of them.

But agreement isn’t the same as capability. A person who defers to you because they’re loyal hasn’t necessarily built the judgement to decide without you, they’ve just learned that deciding without you isn’t their job. You didn’t hire for dependency, you trained it, one avoided disagreement at a time.

This is why the firefighting doesn’t stop even as the team grows. More loyal people just means more people waiting for you to call it.

The difference between someone who’s loyal to you and someone who owns the outcome

Ownership looks different from the outside. It’s the person who tells you the plan won’t work before you’ve committed to it publicly, then makes the call anyway while you’re unreachable and tells you afterwards, not before.

But let’s be honest, that person is harder to manage day to day. They’ll disagree in the room. They might quit if the role stops making sense for them. But they’re the only kind of person who can actually reduce what flows through you, because they’re solving problems on your behalf rather than escalating them to you.

Most founders don’t lack these people because they can’t find them. They lack them because loyalty was the trait being hired for and ownership got lost somewhere in the process.

The people who felt safest to keep were usually the ones who had to leave

I’ve worked with founders since 2014 – here’s something that took me longer to see than it should have: scaling from 150 to 700 people, the departures reduced dependency at the top of the business far more than any new hire did.

I’m talking about people who left or who had to be moved out of roles they’d outgrown. They were almost always the ones who’d been the most loyal in the old sense. They’d built their whole value around staying close to the founder, not around building something that worked without one. The people who stayed and actually scaled the business were the ones who’d argued with leadership more than once and stayed anyway, because they cared about the outcome more than the relationship.

Loyalty, left unexamined, doesn’t just fail to reduce founder dependency, it actively encourages more of the same.

What to do instead of asking who’s loyal

Stop asking who’s loyal. Start asking a sharper question: who on my team could make this specific call without me and be right often enough that I’d trust them to tell me after the event?

If the honest answer is nobody, that’s a decision that’s never actually moved away from the founders. The fix is giving someone real and explicit decision rights on that specific call and living with the discomfort while they get good at it.

That founder discomfort is the tell for us as operating partners. If handing over a decision feels risky, it’s usually because nobody’s ever been allowed to own it enough to learn from it. As a founder you’ve been doing the learning for the whole business, alone, for years.

When did someone on your team last tell you your plan wouldn’t work and stay anyway when you didn’t take the advice? If you can’t answer that quickly, you’ve built an audience, not a team.

First published in Below the Waterline on LinkedIn (opens in a new tab).

Stop being a bottleneck in your own business

Book your free 30 minute
founder review call