Below the Waterline · Issue 7

Culture used to happen by accident.

The culture everyone loved at ten people is quietly fraying at 35. Why founders can’t rely on it spreading by itself, and how to design it on purpose.

By Simon Wakeman, Principal Consultant & Fractional COO
· 3 minute read

When there were ten of you, new starters learnt what mattered by sitting near you.

They heard how you spoke to an unhappy client.

They watched you turn down work that didn’t fit and saw what you did when someone made a mistake.

Nobody wrote any of it down because nobody needed to.

That’s the culture people loved: quick decisions, straight talking and a shared sense of what good looked like.

Now there are 35 of you and some of it is quietly slipping.

You’re finding newer people make calls you wouldn’t have made.

People who’ve been there longest say it “doesn’t feel like it used to”.

And you can’t quite put your finger on when it changed.

Being deliberate about culture is important

Here’s the thing. At ten people nobody designed the culture. As a founder you passed it on, mostly without noticing and just by being in the room.

That works as long as everyone is close enough to the founder to pick it up. But growth breaks it gradually. Somewhere above twenty people or so you stop being in most of the conversations, a layer of managers appears and new people learn how things work from someone who learnt it from someone else.

Every link in this lengthening chain loses a little of the clarity of culture that you loved before. Nobody notices any single one, which is why it feels as if the culture seeped away rather than broke overnight (the boiling frog analogy is often used here!).

The obvious response is to treat it as a values problem. The leadership team goes off-site, agrees five values and puts them on the wall or pins them in Slack. Six months later the values are still on the wall and the behaviour hasn’t changed much at all.

Culture lives in how decisions get made

Values describe how you’d like people to behave. What actually shapes behaviour is the layer underneath: how decisions get made, what people really pay attention to and what happens when something goes wrong.

That’s the practices part of your operating system and it only works if your people and technology are lined up with it too. At ten people the practices lived in your head and the culture came out of them naturally. At 35 the practices have to be built on purpose. Without that the culture runs on the habits each team member has picked up along the way.

In a business I ran I introduced new rituals that felt great for a few months and then quietly lapsed back to what was going on before. At the time I assumed the ritual was the problem and went looking for a better one. Looking back given what I know now, I’d tried bolting a new habit onto poorly defined and communicated decision-making rights that hadn’t changed at all, so it was bound to fail.

Designing it on purpose

Designing culture starts with deciding which few things matter most, then building them into the practices people use every week. You can skip the culture deck at this stage.

A few ways the Mallard team has seen this kind of thing work well:

  • Write down why, not just what. When a decision shows how you want the business to behave, record the reasoning where everyone can find it. New people learn the thinking as well as the outcome.
  • Teach the judgement calls in onboarding. Most onboarding covers tools and processes. Add the three or four situations where people need to know “how we do things here” with real relatable examples from the last year.
  • Decide what your weekly meeting rewards. It’s where culture shows up most often. If it only ever talks about numbers, people will learn that numbers are all that matters.
  • Check your managers can behave in line with your culture. Your team leads are now the main way culture spreads. Ask each of them how they’d explain what matters to someone starting next week and listen for the gaps.

None of this is glamorous and most of it is making explicit what used to be implicit. That can feel a bit sad as if writing it down kind of admits something has been lost as the business grew.

In my experience it works the other way round. Writing it down is how you keep the things that made people want to work with you in the first place.

So here’s a test: ask three people who joined in the last six months what good looks like here, and what happens when someone gets it wrong.

If their answers sound like yours, the culture is spreading as you want it to. If they don’t, it’s time to stop hoping it will scale and start designing it.

First published in Below the Waterline on LinkedIn (opens in a new tab).

Stop being a bottleneck in your own business

Book your free 30 minute
founder review call